Watch this episode without interruptions.
Listen wherever you get your podcasts.
Elisha Wiesel was seven when he pointed at the photograph above his father’s typewriter, a black-and-white house in Sighet, Romania, and asked why he had no grandparents.
He read Night at eleven and mostly went back to baseball. What broke it open came at twenty-one, retracing his father’s steps through Sighet, Auschwitz, and Paris, watching Elie Wiesel hear people who weren’t there, “almost as though he had a radio in his head that nobody else could hear.”
Two things hit at once: pride in a man he had spent his teenage years mistaking for a victim, and fury at the aunt he never had, his father’s murdered little sister, the one who was supposed to spoil him.
Wiesel won’t speak for the dead: “There are very few privileges to being dead. One of them is we shouldn’t put words in the mouths of the dead.” What he will do is describe what he watched for ten thousand hours, a man who fought antisemitism by living Jewish values in public, and who, when his teenage son demanded he choose between humanist and Jew, said: “You’re asking me to split something smaller than the atom.”
The son’s fight is uglier and narrower. He called it a war over language, argues the word “genocide” is being hollowed out, says Holocaust museums have a duty to say so, and has sharp words for Rahm Emanuel’s recent Tel Aviv speech and for a UN that once cut his Holocaust Remembrance Day remarks from seven minutes to three when it learned he’d mention the Uyghurs.
The surprise is how much of it is about joy. Raised at a table where suffering did the talking, he has deliberately given his own kids the other half, the singing, the learning. He describes 3,500 years of Jewish history like gravity: for years it pressed down on him, then it moved above him and began to lift.
