American households owed slightly less at the end of June than they did three months earlier — the first time total household debt has gone down in six years, and only the third such quarter since the last recession.
The New York Fed reported Tuesday that total household debt fell by $13 billion, or 0.1%, to $18.8 trillion in the second quarter. The figure comes from the bank’s Quarterly Report on Household Debt and Credit, built from a nationally representative sample of Equifax credit records.
The decline is real but slim, and most of it traces to one line: mortgages. Mortgage balances dropped by $74 billion to $13.1 trillion. Every other major category went the other way. Credit card balances rose $21 billion to $1.26 trillion, auto loan balances climbed $28 billion to $1.71 trillion, and student loan balances edged down to $1.65 trillion.
Before reading that mortgage number as households paying down their homes, note the mechanical explanation. The $74 billion decline was attributed to a servicer transfer gap — the reporting lag that occurs when a mortgage is handed from one servicer to another and the balance temporarily drops off the credit file. Those balances are expected to reappear. The headline decline, in other words, rests partly on a bookkeeping delay rather than on borrowers retiring debt.
What is not mechanical is the direction of everything else. Ted Rossman, principal consumer finance analyst at Money Management International, said the last quarter-over-quarter decline was six years ago, and the one before that was more than a decade ago. He tied the slip — alongside GDP growth under 2% and a softer jobs market — to an economy that is slowing, and noted that mortgage balances have now declined quarter-over-quarter only three times since 2016. Households borrow less when they are less confident about income, and when higher rates make new borrowing expensive.
The delinquency picture in the same report cuts two ways, and the split is worth understanding because the two numbers appear to contradict each other.
The broad measure improved. The share of loan balances at least 30 days overdue fell to 4.7%, and some measures of newly delinquent debt declined as well. That is the total stock of late debt across all households — and by that yardstick, most borrowers are keeping current.
The flow into new trouble tells a different story. A greater share of borrowers went at least 30 days late on mortgage payments in the second quarter than in any quarter since 2015, and more went 90 days or more past due on car payments than in any quarter since 2010.
Those two facts fit together. The overall pool of delinquent debt can shrink while the rate of new borrowers falling behind rises, because older delinquencies are being cured, written off or resolved faster than new ones arrive. The aggregate looks stable; the entry rate does not. “Overall, consumer debt and delinquencies are plateauing, not plummeting,” Rossman said, adding that considerable strain remains at the household level. Demand for financial counseling at his organization has grown for five straight years.
For businesses, the practical read is a consumer that has stopped expanding its balance sheet. Auto lenders are the most exposed: balances grew $28 billion in the quarter even as serious delinquencies on car loans hit a 16-year high — more lending into a borrower pool where the weakest tier is failing at rates not seen since the aftermath of the financial crisis. Credit card issuers added balances too, which supports interest income in the near term and raises loss exposure if the labor market softens further.
Retailers and anyone selling big-ticket items should read the mortgage line carefully rather than optimistically. Home equity withdrawal and mortgage refinancing have historically funded renovation, appliance and furniture spending. A quarter in which mortgage balances fell — even partly for technical reasons — is not a quarter in which that channel opened up.
For the Fed, the report lands as one more data point on a slowing but not breaking consumer. Falling aggregate delinquency argues against alarm. Rising entry into delinquency on the two loan types most tied to household cash flow, mortgages and cars, argues that the strain is concentrated and building at the bottom.
The one clean conclusion from Tuesday’s data is that after six years of continuous growth, American household borrowing has stopped rising. Whether that is discipline or exhaustion is what the next two quarters will settle.
JBizNews Desk | New York
© JBizNews.com All Rights Reserved. Reproduction or distribution without written permission is prohibited.
