Safety or belonging? The dilemma facing Israeli families raising children abroad

URL has been copied successfully!

Israeli children growing up abroad may be spared the rocket sirens, prolonged uncertainty and daily pressures of war, but they face a different set of challenges involving identity, belonging and, in some countries, antisemitism, according to parents and experts examining the experiences of families who have left Israel since October 7, 2023.

In Israel, children have learned to run to a safe room when a siren sounds, adjust to their fathers being called up for reserve duty yet again, and grow up with stories of bereavement becoming part of everyday life. Children who have moved abroad with their parents since October 7, 2023, have gained distance from the war, but they have also had to adjust to new classrooms, sometimes in a new language, and make new friends. In places where they encounter antisemitism, even the question of whether to reveal that they are from Israel can become a dilemma.

According to an estimate presented to the Knesset Immigration, Absorption and Diaspora Affairs Committee, approximately one million Israelis live abroad.

Some 250,000 have left since the beginning of the war. Many left with children, while others have had children since moving abroad.

Among parents in Israel and the Diaspora, a question is emerging that is difficult to answer with numbers: Who has a happier childhood, Israeli children living abroad or those who have remained in Israel?

An El Al Boeing 737 takes off from Ben-Gurion Airport, March 5, 2026. (credit: YOSSI ALONI/FLASH90)

Even after countless conversations with Israelis in both places, as well as psychologists familiar with the issue, the answer is neither obvious nor unequivocal.

How belonging shapes children’s happiness

Dr. Keren Or-Chen, head of the Interdisciplinary University Clinical Center and one of the founders of the Happiness Sciences Unit at the University of Haifa, says there is insufficient research comparing the two groups.

She distinguishes between a child’s sense of security, satisfaction with life, and the positive emotions they experience in everyday life. A child may feel safer after moving abroad while simultaneously missing friends and the place where they felt they belonged.

“When I look at what affects a child’s happiness, for example, I look at the issue of belonging,” Or-Chen says.

In Israel, she explains, a shared language and culture make it easier for children to form relationships. Abroad, they may grow up between two cultures, and maintaining an Israeli identity, something taken for granted in everyday life in Israel, can sometimes require an effort.

When parents themselves are still uncertain whether the move is for a few years or permanent, that sense of impermanence can make integration more difficult.

Or-Chen also says that what a move abroad can offer a child, including education and opportunities, depends on the destination country and the family’s previous circumstances.

She emphasizes the importance of family life and the child’s relationships with those around them. A child may grow up somewhere quieter and still feel less connected. A child who remains in Israel may find belonging and meaning within their community even during a crisis, while also paying a psychological price for living under a prolonged threat.

Growing up Israeli in Germany

“We’re actually sparing them one thing but creating something else.”

That is how Michal, a 46-year-old artist who grew up on a kibbutz in the Arava, describes the childhood of her three children, ages 11, eight, and four, whom she and her husband are raising in Potsdam, Germany.

The family moved nine years ago, when they had only one child. She recalls that the decision began with curiosity and a desire for adventure. Even now, the word “immigrant” feels too significant a label for her.

At home, the family speaks only Hebrew. The two older children can also read Hebrew, and whenever the family visits Israel, their grandparents and cousins are waiting for them.

“For them, coming to Israel is a kind of paradise,” she says.

At her parents’ home in Ness Ziona, the children pick oranges from a tree in the yard.

But that is the Israel they know from visits, she points out, where they spend time with family without having to attend school. Germany, where they have grown up, is in many respects their natural environment.

Even during visits to Israel, the children have heard sirens and entered a safe room. In Germany, Michal says, that is not part of their daily lives.

She believes they have been spared some of the anxieties experienced by children in Israel during the war years.

Does that mean they are happier?

“That I can’t say.”

According to Michal, the children have not experienced antisemitism directed at them personally.

When they noticed a swastika near their school, it prompted anger and questions, including discussions with children who were not Jewish.

They know that speaking Hebrew could provoke a reaction from someone angry with Israel, but the family speaks Hebrew on the street and on public transportation.

On several occasions, she recalls, people who asked what language they were speaking actually responded positively.

“I think they feel safe in their everyday lives,” she says.

In Germany, she does not have to run to a shelter with them. But the distance also separates them from their extended family and from life in an environment where their language and culture are taken for granted.

That sense of belonging, she says, can also provide a child with security.

Antisemitism in schools abroad

Reports from several countries indicate that antisemitism follows Jewish children into classrooms, schoolyards and on their way to school.

The reports examined do not provide a separate picture of the situation facing Israeli children abroad. They are included in data on Jewish students, without a breakdown that would make it possible to isolate incidents targeting them specifically as Israelis.

In the United States, the Anti-Defamation League documented 825 antisemitic incidents in non-Jewish schools in 2025, including bullying and vandalism involving swastikas.

In Britain, the Community Security Trust (CST) documented 204 incidents involving schools, students and staff during the same year. That was more than double the number recorded in 2022, although it represented a decline from 2024.

An independent review commissioned by the British government and published in October 2026 found that three out of five Jewish students aged 16 to 19 who participated in the survey had experienced or witnessed antisemitism.

In Canada, a study commissioned by the office of the government’s special envoy on combating antisemitism collected reports from 599 Jewish parents concerning 781 incidents in Ontario schools between October 2023 and January 2025.

According to the parents’ reports, 49% of the incidents brought to schools’ attention were never investigated, and nearly one in six involved a teacher or a school-approved activity.

Some children removed Jewish symbols and Hebrew writing to avoid being identified, while others asked their parents not to complain for fear of further harassment.

In Australia, UNESCO presented actual cases reported in schools: a photograph of a Jewish student circulated in a group chat with the caption “gas inhaler”; a child who was told to die in a gas chamber; graffiti reading “Burn the Jews” in a bathroom; and a Jewish student whose assault was filmed and shared online.

Behind these statistics are children such as Eitan Cohen, whose story we reported in Walla in May 2024.

Eitan, then 13, the son of two Israeli doctors and grandson of Rambam Medical Center director Prof. Michael Halberthal, endured threats, humiliation and stone-throwing in Toronto.

According to his family’s account, children threatened him, saying, “We’ll do to you what Hamas did to Israel.” In another incident, they demanded that he bow down to them because they were Muslim and he was Jewish.

After months of appeals that his parents say did not receive an adequate response, hundreds of community members turned out to accompany him to school so that an Israeli child could attend classes safely.

Israelis we speak with generally report that they have not personally experienced antisemitism.

This may be due to preventive measures they take to keep a low profile, a higher threshold for what they consider an “incident,” uncertainty in many cases about whether an encounter constitutes antisemitism or harassment for another reason, and, it must also be said, burying their heads in the sand.

This has happened throughout the generations, including in the 1930s, before the Holocaust.

‘I think they experience the world with much less stress’

Itay and Meital, both 42, are raising three children, ages five, eight and 10, in Porto, Portugal.

“Compared to a Portuguese family, we’re a tribe,” Itay jokes.

Originally from the Haifa area, the couple moved to Porto from Ramot Hashavim nearly four years ago.

They had planned the move even before the COVID-19 pandemic, partly because Itay was already running businesses in Portugal. They also sought a more stable education system.

When the October 7 massacre took place, they had been living in Porto for less than a year.

Their children attend an international school.

Porto has a growing Jewish community, Itay says, but the family does not have the support network provided by Jewish schools and educational institutions in other European cities.

During the first six months after October 7, he recalls, small demonstrations and signs appeared in the city that made him uncomfortable.

Over time, he says, those incidents subsided.

He no longer feels a need to conceal his Israeli identity or avoid wearing a Star of David necklace.

“I think they experience the world with much less stress,” he says of his children.

His daughter has friends from different backgrounds, including a Pakistani Muslim girl, a Chinese girl and a British girl.

For her, he explains, this is simply a natural part of classroom life.

He wonders whether the children will feel differently when they reach adolescence, but for now, he sees how the directness and spontaneity they brought from Israel help them form friendships.

Rather than arranging a get-together weeks in advance, their home has an open-door policy.

A more carefree childhood in Paris

Nachman, 73, and his partner traveled to Paris for two years.

That was 36 years ago.

Their son and daughter were born in Israel and grew up in France. Both now have two children of their own.

The oldest grandchild is seven, and the youngest is one year and four months old.

Nachman speaks Hebrew with them, including on the street.

They maintain contact with relatives in Israel, and until three years ago, they would visit once a year.

On one occasion, his oldest grandson wanted to go to the park wearing a Maccabi Haifa shirt.

“I told him maybe that wasn’t a good idea,” Nachman recalls.

For him, it was a passing remark.

When asked whether his grandchildren are growing up with a sense that they need to be careful about speaking Hebrew or revealing their connection to Israel, he answers immediately.

“Absolutely not. They don’t live in that kind of atmosphere at all.”

The war also reaches them from a distance.

His oldest grandson knows that the apartment belonging to Nachman’s sister in Haifa was damaged when a missile struck nearby.

He heard about it as something that happened to a family member, Nachman explains, without experiencing the tension that accompanies children living under the threat of rocket fire.

Children in Israel, he adds, also have friends who are going through the same period alongside them.

He assumes that shared experience helps them cope.

Nachman sees his grandchildren’s happiness in the small things.

The two older children attend Montessori educational programs, and he watches how they find ways to play and occupy themselves without a phone or television.

They know something is happening in Israel, but when they go down to play in the park, it is almost never what occupies their minds.

When asked whether their childhood in Paris is happier, his answer is clearest when it comes to stress.

In his view, his grandchildren enjoy a more relaxed and carefree childhood.

Share this story:
Share on Facebook
Share by Email
X (Twitter)
Follow Me
Tweet
Whatsapp
LinkedIn
Copy link

This post was originally published on here.