Assaf Moghadam, the new director of Reichman University’s International Institute for Counter-Terrorism, gave The Jerusalem Post two interviews this week. They deserve a careful reading.
His four erosions of old boundaries (young and old, one ideology and many, terror and conventional war, local and international conflict) describe the field as it now stands.
Yet every boundary sits outside the person. None asks what happens inside a human being before he picks up the knife, the rifle, or the suicide vest.
A discipline without a developmental account of the mind will keep charting the weather while the climate goes unexamined. Sun Tzu urged knowing the enemy, and Carl von Clausewitz wrote of the enemy’s will and moral forces.
Developmental psychology and psychoanalysis did not yet exist. They have much to add to our understanding of “political” violence.
Take age. Moghadam warns that “terrorists are also getting younger,” with 12- and 13-year-olds now appearing in plots in Israel and Europe. He treats this as a recruitment trend, helped along by social media and AI.
But a 12-year-old recruit was formed long before any algorithm found him. Recruiters harvest a mind that was already prepared. The decisive years are the first three: in the relationship between infant and mother, and in the household’s rules for shame, honor, and rage.
A boy or girl raised in a shame-honor culture, and I include shame-honor families in the West, learns that humiliation can be repaired only by making someone else suffer it. His hatred is not first political. It is first domestic.
Take ideology. Moghadam observes that far-right, far-left, and jihadi currents now cross-pollinate, and that antisemitism supplies the glue. He is right. These are artificially constructed linguistic categories that do not take into account human development.
Therefore, he stops where the question begins. What is the glue made of?
Ideology is less a belief than a psychological prosthesis for a capacity that never developed in the mind, a cognitive deficit in thinking: the capacity to hold love and hatred toward the same person, to tolerate ambivalence, to live with one’s own badness without handing it to someone else.
A mind without that capacity splits the world into the pure and the contaminated, and the Jew is the oldest container for the contaminated. Change the ideology and the psychological prosthesis stays the same. That is why the horseshoe bends.
Deborah Lipstadt, the former US special envoy for antisemitism, has also thrown the horseshoe metaphor out the window, replacing it with a Venn model, but here too the problem persists. The diagram does not account for early childhood development.
Take warfare. On October 7, 2023, Hamas invaded like an army, as Moghadam says. It also mutilated bodies and hunted families in their homes. The military half of that sentence can be mapped with tactics and arsenals. The other half cannot.
And here too, Cochav Elkayam-Levy and Irwin Cotler had to create a new legal term for the slaughter of the family: kinocide.
This legal term is revealing because it points back to the “family,” which I read as early child-rearing practices in Gazan culture that have managed to keep the population terrified for years, if not centuries.
Yet we don’t bother to integrate an understanding of what went wrong early on. We keep on reinventing the wheel.
Putting the child first
Now take Gaza. Moghadam says deradicalization is possible but is a project of “20 to 40 years,” and that it requires undermining those with a stake in radicalization. He points to children not yet born, and he is right to look there.
He also holds that, to a child in Gaza, it does not matter how justified Israel’s war was, and he urges Israelis to be more sympathetic. Sympathy is decent, but it is not an intervention.
The Gazan child’s hostility did not begin with our war. Hamas has shaped childhood in Gaza since 2007, and the war then becomes the story a prepared mind tells itself.
An adult cannot be argued out of a psychological prosthesis he or she needs to stay whole. All of this precedes changing “the textbook syndrome.” Not that it isn’t important, but it is not early enough.
What can be done is to change what happens between birth and age five: trained caregivers, secure attachment, nurseries, and kindergartens where anger can be spoken instead of enacted, and mothers who are protected rather than abused and silenced.
Understanding shame-honor cultures entails understanding that the effort to go through the critical stage of separation and individuation from the mother entails speaking dugri, bluntly, with the population, policy experts, and their leaders.
It is time to say this is your problem, not ours; though left unattended, it becomes ours. When we say it, we will have more empathy for the Gazans.
It is not just about what happened on October 7. It is about taking responsibility for how they treat their own children.
A child who has been held does not need an ideology to feel intact. Nothing else will shorten Moghadam’s 40 years.
Moghadam says ICT will broaden its scope and deepen its international partnerships.
I offer a direction for both: add clinicians and developmental psychoanalysts to the table, where political scientists and strategists already sit. Half of them should be women.
The terrorist was a child first. Golda Meir is credited with saying that peace will come when they love their children more than they hate us. She was right.
The writer is a psychoanalyst, counterterrorism scholar, and the author of A Soldier’s Guide to Hamas’s Genocidal Psychosis – The Unconscious in Psychological Warfare: Beyond Ideology, Before Words (Atzmaut Press, Tel Aviv, 2025).


