Canada could have half a million Jews by 2070, nearly three times as many as France. That was the projection that surprised me in Pew Research Center’s report this week on the future of religion. In 2020, France had about 460,000 Jews and Canada had 350,000.
I expected the French Jewish community to grow smaller. A senior rabbi in France told me on Thursday that Pew’s projection of 180,000 Jews there by 2070 sounded right to him. Consider the families of the rabbis and lay leaders who keep Jewish life going in France today. Many have children who live in Israel. In some families, all the children are here. Who will run the schools and synagogues when their parents retire?
The Canadian figure deserves a closer look, particularly footnote 62. Pew lacked reliable data on how many Canadians raised Jewish continue to identify as Jewish by religion. Its model assumes that all of them do, while allowing for others to begin identifying as Jewish. The researchers acknowledge that their estimate for Canada may be high.
As a Zionist, I welcome the prospect that 62% of the world’s Jews could live in Israel by 2070, up from 46% in 2020. I find it entirely plausible. Pew expects Israel’s Jewish population to grow from 6.8 million to 11.1 million, mainly because Israeli Jews are relatively young and births outnumber deaths. There’s a qualification worth keeping in mind, especially in America. Pew’s Israeli figures come from a population register that includes secular Jews. An American who reports no religion and identifies as Jewish through family or culture is counted among the unaffiliated.
I’m interested in what happens to the other four-in-10. An Israeli government that takes pride in how many French Jews have made aliyah, the Hebrew term for Jewish immigration to Israel, ought to care about the Jewish education available to a child growing up in Lyon.
A few days ago, someone told me my old reporting beat, Diaspora affairs, was becoming valuable. I asked him why. Israelis were paying closer attention to what was happening to Jews overseas, he said. They also wanted to know whether another wave of aliyah was coming.
French Jews see Israeli support whether making Aliyah or back in France
In October, Israeli employers went to Paris to recruit at an aliyah fair that drew about 2,000 people. That same month, a principal and a teacher from the city’s École Juive Moderne traveled to Jerusalem for a Jewish education summit that Israel’s Diaspora Affairs Ministry helped organize. The employers were looking for people who might move to Israel. The educators were going back to their classrooms in Paris. I’d count both trips as Zionist successes.
Last week, the Israeli cabinet approved the outline of a plan developed by the Prime Minister’s Office and the Jewish Federations of North America to expand access to Jewish day schools in the United States and Canada. Israel committed NIS 100 million, about $32 million. The federations say they will raise a matching sum. When I started covering this beat, I’d have had a hard time imagining an Israeli cabinet committing that kind of money so a child in Canada could attend a Jewish school close to home.
For American Jews, one of the most consequential projections in Pew’s report concerns their neighbors. Worldwide, Muslims could outnumber Christians by 2035, even as both populations grow. By 2070, a majority of the world’s Christians could live in sub-Saharan Africa. The Hindu population is expected to grow and the Buddhist population to shrink. The share of people with no religious affiliation could fall worldwide from 24% to 17%. In the US, where most Diaspora Jews would still live, it could rise from 30% to 41%.
In a separate Pew survey in March, 22% of religiously unaffiliated American adults viewed Israel favorably, compared with 65% of white evangelical Protestants. This fall, the Public Religion Research Institute asked about aid. Among unaffiliated Americans, 77% thought Washington was giving Israel too much financial and military support. Among white evangelical Protestants, 43% agreed.
If those differences persist, public backing for US aid to Israel could weaken as the unaffiliated share grows. Much will also depend on decisions Israeli governments make. An American who asks what her tax dollars are paying for deserves an answer she can weigh on its merits.
Israel’s Diaspora affairs must be treated seriously by the next government
The next Israeli government should treat Diaspora affairs as a strategic responsibility, with backing across party lines and close cooperation with the Aliyah and Integration Ministry, which helps newcomers settle. Whether the work belongs in the Prime Minister’s Office is a fair debate. I care more about who does it. An immigrant may have a head start. I’d like a minister who can take questions from young Jews in their own language and understand why two children raised in the same Jewish home might choose to live in different countries.
Natan Sharansky once held that portfolio. You could disagree with his politics and still want your children to hear him. He fought for the right of Soviet Jews to leave for Israel and helped found the Moscow Helsinki Group to document human rights abuses. He spent nine years in Soviet prisons and labor camps, made aliyah the day he was freed in 1986, and later chaired the Jewish Agency for Israel. A Jewish teenager in Montreal could recognize her own people’s story in his. Her non-Jewish classmate could understand why a man should be free to speak his mind and decide where to live.
Sharansky sometimes hesitates over a word in Russian, Hebrew, or English. His humor travels easily in all three. His wife, Avital, told Rabbi Avi Weiss about their reunion after 12 years apart. Natan’s first words to her were “Sorry I’m late.”
Too few people in Israeli public life today have that kind of standing among young Jews abroad. I’d like the next minister responsible for Diaspora affairs to sit down with teenagers at a Jewish school in France and ask which Israeli they would most like to meet, and why. I’d be especially interested in the answer from the girl who plans to spend her life in France. She has as much claim on that minister’s attention as her brother who is packing for Israel.
