UK Tribunal Confirms Secret Apple Notice, Rejects Government’s Secrecy Claim

Archive photograph of an iPhone 17 Pro in December 2025.
URL has been copied successfully!

Archive: iPhone 17 Pro, December 2025. Olgierd Rudak / CC0; cropped.

A British tribunal confirmed Thursday that the government had served Apple with a secret technical capability notice, rejecting the Home Office’s argument that acknowledging the order would damage national security. The ruling opens more of the legal challenge to public scrutiny but does not decide whether the order is lawful.

The dispute concerns government powers to require technology companies to maintain capabilities that can support surveillance. Reuters has reported that the order seeks access to encrypted Apple customer data. The notice’s precise contents remain undisclosed, and Thursday’s ruling does not establish that Apple has installed a back door or provided access to customers’ encrypted data.

In its November 19 judgment, the Investigatory Powers Tribunal said the government had not shown that confirming the notice’s existence would harm national security, given extensive public reporting, statements by American officials and briefings the tribunal concluded had been authorized by British officials.

The tribunal said much, but not all, of the cases brought by Apple and privacy campaigners could now be heard in public. Questions about which details of the notice can be disclosed will be decided later. It also issued separate private and closed judgments containing material it said could not be published without damaging the public interest.

Apple’s first challenge began in early 2025 and was later dismissed after a change in circumstances. Apple brought its second claim in July 2026, according to the judgment. The tribunal also cited an October 2025 Financial Times report that Britain had issued a replacement notice after the United States objected to the original demand.

A substantive hearing previously planned for December 2026 is no longer practical, the tribunal said. The parties expect to agree directions aimed at a hearing in the first half of 2027. Apple’s claims include challenges to the government’s legal powers, its consultation process and the notice’s compatibility with privacy rights.

Liberty and Privacy International are separately challenging the legal regime for these notices under the Investigatory Powers Act 2016, alongside two individual claimants. Liberty director Akiko Hart called Thursday’s decision “a victory for transparency.” The underlying challenges remain unresolved.

JBizNews Desk | London

© JBizNews.com. All rights reserved. Unauthorized reproduction or redistribution is strictly prohibited.

Share this story:
Share on Facebook
Share by Email
X (Twitter)
Follow Me
Tweet
Whatsapp
LinkedIn
Copy link